Reflections on the Scottish Independence Movement
Immediately noticeable is the perspective from which the Scottish independence movement is being assessed—primarily through the political dynamics of party politics, especially those at Westminster. It raises the question of whether this approach truly assists in developing a meaningful analysis of the current situation.
A striking point is the labeling of Alba as reactionary in Scottish politics, primarily due to its advocacy for women’s safe spaces and the protection of established equal rights. This characterization resonates with my experience—it’s a key reason I, as a communist, became involved with Alba in its initial stages, as did many women from the left within the SNP.
Shifts in Political Trust
A significant political transformation over the past five years is the growing skepticism among working-class individuals towards all political parties, which has resulted in many choosing not to participate in elections. This sentiment, I believe, has affected Alba as well.
The Emergence of a Liberation Movement
An exciting development within the grassroots Scottish independence movement is the establishment of a liberation initiative through organizations like Salvo and Liberation, founded by Sara Salyers alongside supporters such as Professor Alf Baird. Their goal is to explore Scotland’s ancient constitutional rights and highlight the numerous breaches of the Treaty of Union of 1707—an international agreement that can be revoked if, as suggested, it is a “voluntary union.”
The aim is to initiate an international challenge that underscores Westminster’s democratic deficit. While some dismiss this as whimsical due to their entrenched views of Westminster politics, I ask: can you name a successful independence movement that achieved its freedom without a dedicated liberation struggle?
Grassroots Activity and Media Representation
The grassroots independence movement has not been idle since 2014; however, unless you are actively involved, you might not be aware of its robust activities, as they often go unreported in both academic forums and mainstream media.
There have been vigorous campaigns addressing topics such as Scottish colonialism, the creation of a Scottish currency, and improving transport connectivity, encompassing maritime resources and the formation of a Scottish constitution inspired by Swiss models of democracy. We’ve certainly been industrious!
The Labour Party’s Concerns
It has always puzzled me that the Scottish Labour Party’s leadership seemed indifferent to the disparities in resource distribution and expenditure between Scotland and the southeast of England.
It is encouraging to see voices like Greg’s tackling independence issues, and we need more advocates like him. How can we confront the threat of Reform UK if we don’t engage with communities in housing schemes and tenement closes, as we did during the 2014 campaign?
Defining British vs. Scottish Government Problems
A thought-provoking question arises: When is a governmental issue British rather than Scottish? The answer seems to be—it’s primarily an English concern. Recent events, including racially charged anti-asylum-seeker riots and discussions around drug-related deaths, underscore this distinction, particularly when Scottish journalists inadvertently highlight how such issues are often rooted in English dynamics rather than Scottish realities.
While Labour and Conservative parties obsess over Scotland’s NHS issues, the advocate of Brexit, who champions the wealthy British elite, may ironically benefit from the Scottish electorate’s misguided support for Reform UK under the illusion of fundamental reform. However, such governmental influence is likely to exacerbate inequality and further widen the UK’s already vast wealth gap.
The True Costs of the Monarchy
I challenge Republic Scotland or any journalist free from employment constraints to analyze the total financial burden of the royal family on the UK. This examination should include expenses from even the simplest tasks, such as unclogging a toilet in Balmoral, maintaining royal residences, and providing security for their visits—often in settings like food banks that could seem more about self-promotion than genuine concern.
Historical Context and Future Considerations
The monarchy seemingly exploits the lax financial oversight within the UK for minimal return. Additionally, the exaggerated claims about tourism might also be pertinent in any assessment, not to mention the royal family’s questionable identity as British subjects.
As I prepare to visit the Museum of Scotland, I reflect on whether they still exhibit a working model of “the Maiden,” a historic artifact that symbolizes Scotland’s rich heritage.
Political Commentary on Current Leadership Choices
Recent reports suggest that Trump contemplated rejecting Lord Mandelson as Starmer’s ambassador nominee to the US, a notion I find preposterous. Under Tony Blair’s administration, Mandelson was infamously enchanted by wealth and Russian oligarchs. Given this background, he appears to be an ideal match for the role.
