Gender Differences in Exercise: Men Need More for Heart Health
By Gigen Mammoser — Fact-checked by Jennifer Chesak, MSJ
Key Findings
A recent extensive study has uncovered that men might need to engage in about twice the amount of weekly physical activity as women to obtain equivalent cardiovascular benefits. This study utilized data from over 85,000 participants in the UK Biobank, aimed at understanding how physical activity impacts heart health differently across genders.
Exercise Recommendations
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the American Heart Association (AHA) suggest that adults should aim for a minimum of 150 minutes of moderate to vigorous physical activity each week. Despite this guideline, findings indicate that women who meet or exceed this threshold experience greater reductions in heart disease risk compared to men.
The Gender Gap in Physical Activity
The study reveals a persistent “gender gap” where women are less likely to meet exercise guidelines despite exhibiting better overall heart health benefits from physical activity. According to the CDC, less than half of U.S. adults (47%) meet the suggested activity levels, highlighting a significant public health concern.
Insights from Experts
“This study aligns with many previous analyses which indicate that physical activity benefits cardiovascular health for both genders, though the risk reduction observed for women is typically greater,” noted Dr. Bethany Barone Gibbs, a professor at West Virginia University’s School of Public Health.
Dr. Gibbs emphasized, “While the gradient of benefit favors women, the key takeaway is the health benefits afforded by regular physical activity for all.”
Dissecting the Findings
The research also showed that women who achieved 150 minutes of physical activity experienced a 22% lower risk of coronary heart disease (CHD), opposed to a 17% risk reduction for men. Interestingly, to experience similar benefits in reducing CHD risk, men needed to log in excess of 530 minutes of exercise weekly, well beyond the recommended guidelines.
In examining those with existing CHD, active women had a 70% reduced mortality risk, whereas active men only had a 19% decrease. To achieve equivalent mortality benefits, men needed to engage in approximately 85 minutes of weekly activity compared to just 51 minutes for women.
Addressing Barriers to Exercise
Experts like Dr. Denice Ichinoe from the University of Nevada highlight that women often confront barriers to regular exercise, such as time constraints due to work commitments or caregiving responsibilities. “Finding time to exercise can be particularly challenging for mothers, especially those postpartum,” she mentioned.
Both Dr. Ichinoe and Dr. Gibbs recommend strategies for increasing physical activity, including:
- Starting small with shorter periods of activity throughout the day.
- Considering everyday activities such as gardening or cleaning as forms of exercise.
- Opting to walk or bike for short errands instead of driving.
- Engaging in enjoyable physical activities regularly.
- Gradually increasing the duration and intensity of exercise to build consistency.