Transgender Representations: Montana Rep. Zooey Zephyr Triumphs
Montana state Representative Zooey Zephyr, who identifies as a transgender woman and was recently reelected, will not face restrictions preventing her from using women’s restrooms upon her return to the state legislature.
This significant development follows a failed attempt by the Joint Rules Committee to implement a rule barring Zephyr and other trans women from accessing women’s restrooms. Reports indicate that a notable number of Republican members voted against the proposal, showcasing bipartisan support against the measure, as highlighted by Ari Drennen from Media Matters.
Zephyr Expresses Gratitude
In response to the decision, Zephyr shared her relief and appreciation for her colleagues, particularly those from the Republican Party. She remarked, “I’m happy to see that this proposed ban failed and am grateful for my colleagues—especially my Republican colleagues—who recognized this as a distraction from the work we were elected to do. I’m ready to represent my constituents and look forward to working on behalf of the people of Montana.”
Continued Representation of Trans Voices
Additionally, Montana is represented by another trans legislator, SJ Howell, who identifies as nonbinary. The implications of this proposed rule regarding Howell’s restroom access remain unclear. The Advocate has reached out to Howell for clarification on the matter.
On the Joint Rules Committee, the Montana House members voted 12-10 against the rule. While the Senate members voted 11-7 in its favor, the proposal failed due to needing a majority from both chambers to pass.
Origin of the Proposed Rule
The rule was introduced by Republican Representative Jerry Schillinger, who referenced a controversial documentary titled *What Is a Woman?* produced by the right-leaning platform, The Daily Wire. Questions arose during discussions about how to measure or assess a legislator’s gender, with some lawmakers expressing concerns over the practical application and ramifications of such a rule.
Republican Representative Ed Buttrey voiced doubts about the feasibility of the proposed testing, asking, “If there’s a question over the chromosomes of a legislator, then does the legislature itself force the legislator to take some type of test?” Meanwhile, Representative David Bedey pointed out that the proposed action would likely draw national attention and distract from legislative goals.
Zephyr’s Previous Challenges
In 2023, Zephyr faced exclusion from the Montana House chamber after asserting that colleagues who supported banning gender-affirming care for transgender youth would have “blood on their hands.” While Republican lawmakers demanded an apology, Zephyr stood firm, stating that her remarks were justified. The controversy culminated in her temporary ban from legislative activities, leading her to file a lawsuit against the state; however, the suit was dismissed, upholding her exclusion for the remainder of that session.
A New Session Ahead
As the new legislative session approaches, Zooey Zephyr is set to return, reinstated with full legislative privileges. This development marks an important moment for representation and advocacy in Montana’s political landscape.
Broader Context in LGBTQ+ Advocacy
Currently, trans activists have called upon incoming U.S. Representative Sarah McBride, the first openly trans person elected to Congress, to oppose a restroom ban imposed by U.S. House Speaker Mike Johnson. However, McBride has indicated her commitment to adhere to House rules while expressing that others should not have to endure such restrictions.
This ongoing discourse highlights the resilience and determination within the LGBTQ+ community, as representatives like Zephyr pave the way for future advocacy and representation in government.
