A recent study explores the effects of heading the ball in women’s football, revealing no significant impact on balance but an intriguing change in fine motor skills, highlighting potential neurological implications.
Study: The effect of football (soccer) heading on gross and fine motor control in women. Image credit: Fotokostic/Shutterstock.com
The impact of heading the ball in women’s football has been the subject of increased scrutiny. Though the act of heading itself does not seem to undermine gross motor control, a recent study published in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living indicates it may subtly affect fine motor functions.
The Risks of Heading in Football
Heading the ball is fundamental to football strategy, accounting for roughly 32.5% of contestable goals during the 2022 Women’s World Cup. Current findings suggest that the average forces experienced during such actions fall within limits that are not deemed harmful for brain injury.
However, prior research has pointed towards a potential connection between repeated headers and an increased risk of neurodegenerative conditions. For example, following a standard heading session, some players have displayed immediate adverse effects, like heightened corticomotor inhibition and diminished memory capabilities. This underscores the necessity for a deeper understanding of both the short-term and long-term outcomes of such head impacts.
Motor control assessments—rated by evaluating the ability to regulate and coordinate movements—serve as useful tools in studying neurological impacts from heading. Gross motor control is typically gauged through balance tests, which reflect the intricacies of various physical mechanisms involving both cortical and subcortical pathways.
Research results regarding the effect of heading on standing balance have been inconsistent. While some studies suggest impaired balance post-heading, others found no significant changes. Notably, female athletes appear more susceptible to harmful alterations in white matter microstructure following heading compared to their male counterparts, bringing to light the importance of further investigation into the neurological effects on female players.
Study Overview
This study enlisted 19 female footballers from the University of Exeter, comprising ten defenders, five midfielders, and four forwards, all averaging 21 years old with around 11 years of playing experience.
After completing familiarization with testing procedures, participants took part in either a heading protocol—designed to simulate match conditions—or a control scenario where they remained seated for one hour. The heading protocol involved repeatedly heading an official UEFA Women’s Champions League football, launched six times per hour from approximately 15 meters away, at a velocity of 40 ± 5 km/h to mirror in-game intensity.
Subsequently, cardiovascular assessments were conducted, followed by tasks measuring balance and grip strength. The precision finger grip test (PFG) involved tasks done both with full vision and without vision, while the balance task required maintaining a double-leg stance.
Key Findings
The results indicated significant changes in fine motor control after the heading exercise. Specifically, there was a marked decrease in oscillations in force production (OFP) tremor frequency during the non-vision PFG trials after heading was carried out. However, gross motor control levels remained unaffected.
Though a higher value of center of pressure (CoP) sway velocity was noted, especially in the eyes-closed condition for both the heading and control groups, no statistically significant shifts were found in gross motor performance.
Moreover, the medium effect size observed in tremor frequency post-heading suggests that fine motor control may be affected, even in the absence of changes to gross motor skills.
Conclusions and Future Directions
This study provides valuable insights, showing that heading during a standard game does not alter gross motor control but may influence fine motor control. Researchers recommend further investigations that encompass various ball speeds beyond the 40 km/h standard used, as well as longitudinal studies to better understand the long-term effects on fine motor skills.
Future studies could leverage brain imaging and electrophysiological assessments to explore the underlying neurobiological mechanisms that dictate these motor control changes resulting from heading.
Download your PDF copy now!
